Holiday Commercials: the Best and Worst

By Kersten Jaeger on December 21, 2012

The Worst

5. Toys”R”Us

Toys”R”Us decided this year to go with the “kids acting like adults” theme, having children do a news broadcast of their great deals. This commercial relies on the assumption that anything with kids in it is automatically cute. Unfortunately for Toys”R”Us, that’s not always the case. These kids yell the store sales at you in more of an annoying rather than endearing manner. The visual display of a news report is interesting and well done, but there isn’t anything witty or adorable to really make this an effective commercial. It goes straight from annoying to boring, without including anything to stop someone from pressing mute, and it ends with a man asking the exact question I was thinking: “Why?”

4. Old Navy

As hilarious as National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation was, this commercial doesn’t get as many laughs as it does groans. While Chevy Chase attempts to light up his house Griswold-style, all of the people around him suddenly get magically color-changing pants. Not only do we have to watch them try to sell their colored pants, but we get a lovely taste of Chevy Chase’s singing. This doesn’t do much to make these clothes desirable, because it now associates Old Navy clothes with a tone-deaf rendition of “Joy to the World”.

3. Folgers Coffee

Ok, this commercial has gone on long enough. You know, the one where the brother comes home and hands a present to his sister, who then sticks the ribbon on him because he’s her present this year? Well, I hope my present this year is a discontinuation of this advertisement. It’s been running since 2009. Seriously, guys, let’s come up with a new idea. It’s even a remake of an older Folgers commercial that welcomes a returning brother home (also cheesy and overdone). Seems to me like the advertising department at Folgers could use some of that coffee to help them come up with new ideas.

2. Sprint

Dogs barking a Christmas carol! That’s entertaining, but doesn’t do a whole lot to sell a cell phone. Multiple phones are being passed around in this commercial with cats and dogs that are barking and meowing “Deck the Halls”, which doesn’t show off any phone capabilities other than being able to play annoying videos. This isn’t a particularly new technology for phones and the animal video compilation seems more suited to a youtube video rather than a commercial.

1. Crate & Barrel

So it is often said that less is more, but this commercial hardly has anything. It pairs words with an “&” between them, ending with Crate&Barrel. It doesn’t mention any products, any sales, or anything about the store at all really. It’s boring and ineffective, even though it manages to sneak in Merry&Christmas.

The Best

6. L.L. Bean

The commercial opens with cute little children sitting on a couch waiting for Santa. It’s a little cheesy, yes, but it uses cheesy effectively, pairing it with adorable. The children are wearing L.L. Bean headlamps, and it sells its “products that last” by showing the lights still shining while the children sleep through the night.

5. JC Penny

The first thing this commercial does right is it starts with a catchy song. With the upbeat music playing it then creates wreaths and christmas trees with JC Penny items. It’s a cute holiday display that shows off its products. It’s also very aesthetically pleasing to watch as the clothes and purses become different designs. All in all, it’s entertaining and well done.

4. AT&t

Starting with an attempted ploy by two boys to convince their parents that they authentically want iPads to work on math, this commercial shows just how awesome iPads are as the parents enjoy the games. With clever writing in the commercial it authentically convinces that the iPad is really fun and subtly works in the special AT&T deal. This is a good sell and it’s funny at the same time.

3. Coca Cola

For years, Coca Cola has created Santa-themed commercials, and this one does not disappoint. As a grocery store clerk is working for the holidays, Santa begins tilting his snow globe (in which we all live, of course) and the clerk is whisked home for the holidays in a shopping cart. Not only are the effects really cool in this video, but its got the Christmas spirit aspect that really makes you want to buy a Coke and support this kind of message.

2. Travelers Insurance

Okay, this commercial really knows how to do it; it’s manipulative genius. It has an adorable dog that gets a bone and is followed by a bunch of other dogs on its way home, so it’s cute already. It jumps through a fence and give the bone to a poor sick dog in its dog house with a cone collar. I challenge anyone to watch this and not at least think “awww.” Of course, all of the other dogs gather around and stop trying to steal the bone. This is truly heart-warming and it makes me want to trust Travelers Insurance! Yes, it’s convincing. It is obviously manipulative, but it works. Travelers appears to be a company that cares, all because of this advertising.

1. Safeway

First of all, this commercial is pretty. Second of all, it’s catchy. Overall, it’s convincing. With a really cool background of chalk drawings including snowflakes and wreaths, the commercial proceeds with a clever and catchy rhyme. Not only do the pictures stay in your mind because they are so pretty, but the rhyme is stuck in your head for at least the next five minutes, which is longer than most commercials. It also works its sales into the rhymes which is extremely effective. I can still picture the chalk outline of $6.99 next to Starbucks coffee. Nicely done, Safeway.

What do you think the best and worst Holiday commercials are this season?

 

Follow Uloop

Apply to Write for Uloop News

Join the Uloop News Team

Discuss This Article

Back to Top ↑

Log In

Contact Us

Upload An Image

Please select an image to upload
Note: must be in .png, .gif or .jpg format
OR
Provide URL where image can be downloaded
Note: must be in .png, .gif or .jpg format

By clicking this button,
you agree to the terms of use

By clicking "Create Alert" I agree to the Uloop Terms of Use.

Image not available.

Add a Photo

Please select a photo to upload
Note: must be in .png, .gif or .jpg format